Phyllis Potter: The Life, Love, And Tragic Death Of Fred Astaire’s First Wife

Public interest in Phyllis Potter, also known as Phyllis Livingston Baker or Phyllis Astaire, has grown in recent years as classic Hollywood fans revisit the life of legendary dancer Fred Astaire. Phyllis was not only a respected American socialite but also Astaire’s first wife and the mother of three children—one from her first marriage and two with Astaire. Her influence on Astaire’s personal stability and professional success made her an important but often overlooked figure in old Hollywood history. Her tragic death from lung cancer at just 46 shocked the entertainment world and left Astaire devastated for decades. This article explores her verified biography, early life, marriages, children, role in Hollywood history, illness, death, legacy, and continued remembrance, offering a detailed and factual look into her remarkable life story.

Profile Bio: Phyllis Potter

Who Was Phyllis Potter?

Phyllis Livingston Baker was born on May 4, 1908, in Boston, Massachusetts, and died on September 13, 1954, in Los Angeles, California. She was an American socialite known for her elegance, refined upbringing, and deep ties to elite East Coast families. Her fame expanded significantly after becoming the first wife of legendary dancer and actor Fred Astaire, whom she married in 1933. In Hollywood circles, she was admired for her grace, intelligence, and unwavering support of her husband’s artistic career. Because she lived in an era with fewer interviews and limited public exposure, much of her life remains private and documented only through verified historical records. Still, her influence on Astaire and her presence in Hollywood’s Golden Age continue to spark interest today.

Early Life & Family Background

Phyllis Potter came from a respected and affluent Boston family. She was the daughter of Dr. Harold Woods Baker, a renowned physician, and Caroline E. Livingston, a member of the prominent Livingston family with deep American historical roots. After her parents separated during her childhood, Phyllis moved to New York and lived with her wealthy aunt and uncle, Maud Livingston and Henry Worthington Bull, a senior partner at Harriman & Company. This transition exposed her to New York’s high society and shaped her refined social etiquette and upbringing. Her privileged environment allowed her access to elite cultural, social, and educational opportunities. All verified information portrays her as a well-educated, poised, and socially respected young woman who later moved effortlessly into elite Manhattan social circles.

Education & Upbringing

Growing up in an affluent and socially prominent family, Phyllis received a private education typical of high-society children of her time. She was educated in Boston and later in New York, gaining exposure to the arts, social etiquette, and charitable circles. Her upbringing revolved around cultural events, private gatherings, equestrian activities, golf clubs, and society functions that shaped her refined public image. While specific school names are not documented publicly, her polished demeanor, social confidence, and ability to navigate elite environments suggest strong academic and cultural training. Her early life experiences prepared her for the sophisticated world of New York society and later for her role as the wife of one of Hollywood’s greatest entertainers. Every verified detail portrays her as cultured, intelligent, and deeply well-mannered.

First Marriage to Eliphalet Nott Potter III

Before marrying Fred Astaire, Phyllis married Eliphalet Nott Potter III, a member of a wealthy and influential New York family. They married on December 27, 1927, in Manhattan when Phyllis was just 19 years old. The couple had one son, Eliphalet IV, affectionately known as Peter. Their marriage, however, faced difficulties, and they ultimately divorced in 1932. Verified records do not indicate personal or private reasons for the separation, and no speculation is necessary. After the divorce, Phyllis returned to her active social life in New York, where she would soon attract the attention of Fred Astaire, who was rising rapidly in his entertainment career.

Meeting Fred Astaire: The Beginning of a Hollywood Love Story

The love story between Phyllis Potter and Fred Astaire began at a golf luncheon hosted by Mrs. Graham Fair Vanderbilt, a well-known social figure. Astaire had actually noticed Phyllis earlier at the famous Belmont Park horse races, drawn to her beauty and elegance. Once properly introduced, Astaire became deeply interested, pursuing her consistently for nearly two years. His mother and sister disapproved of the match, believing she lacked show-business experience, but Astaire ignored all objections. Their relationship blossomed through shared interests, mutual admiration, and emotional compatibility. Their growing affection eventually led to a marriage that would become one of Hollywood’s most admired personal partnerships.

Marriage to Fred Astaire (A Hollywood Partnership)

Phyllis and Fred Astaire married on July 12, 1933, beginning a partnership that played a key role during some of Astaire’s most successful years in Hollywood. Despite public curiosity and family objections, their relationship proved deeply loving and stable. The couple established homes in both California and New York, balancing Astaire’s hectic film schedule with a peaceful family life. Phyllis became Astaire’s emotional anchor, providing comfort during stressful productions and offering encouragement throughout his demanding career. Their marriage coincided with Astaire’s Golden Age in film, including his iconic partnership with Ginger Rogers. Behind the scenes, Phyllis created a warm, grounded environment that allowed Astaire to thrive creatively and personally.

Children With Fred Astaire

Phyllis and Fred Astaire had two children together, forming a close and loving family. Their first child, Fred Astaire Jr., was born in 1936. He later made a brief appearance alongside his father in the film Midas Run and eventually became a rancher and charter pilot. Their daughter, Ava Astaire, was born in 1942 and has played an important role in preserving and promoting her father’s legacy through documentaries and public appearances. Phyllis balanced motherhood, social responsibilities, and her role as Astaire’s emotional support with grace. Their home life was known to be loving, stable, and respectful, providing a private sanctuary far from the Hollywood spotlight.

Phyllis Potter’s Role in Fred Astaire’s Career

Phyllis played a significant role in Astaire’s success, offering emotional stability and encouragement during his most important film years. Their harmonious marriage helped shape Astaire’s cheerful and sophisticated on-screen persona. Many Hollywood historians note that Phyllis gave Astaire the confidence he needed to navigate a demanding career in film and dance. She also reportedly encouraged his professional partnership with Ginger Rogers, which became one of the most iconic pairings in cinema history. Although she stayed out of the spotlight, Astaire often credited Phyllis privately for her unwavering support and her ability to maintain balance in their family life.

Health Decline & Battle With Lung Cancer

In the early 1950s, Phyllis Potter’s health began to decline due to lung cancer. Verified accounts state that she underwent radiation therapy and surgery, both common treatments at the time. Despite medical efforts, her condition deteriorated rapidly. Her final months were emotionally difficult for the entire Astaire family, especially Fred, who struggled to continue working while caring for his wife. The illness was swift and severe, leaving little hope for recovery. Astaire later described this as one of the darkest periods in his life, as he tried to balance professional commitments with overwhelming personal grief. Her decline deeply affected him and marked a turning point in his emotional and professional journey.

Death of Phyllis Potter (1954)

Phyllis Potter died on September 13, 1954, in Los Angeles at the age of 46, succumbing to lung cancer. She was buried at Oakwood Memorial Park in Chatsworth, California, where fans and family continue to pay respects. News of her death spread quickly throughout Hollywood, prompting condolences from actors, directors, and studio executives who admired Astaire and respected his personal loss. Her passing occurred while Astaire was working on the film Daddy Long Legs, and the shock nearly caused him to abandon the production entirely. Her death is remembered as one of the great personal tragedies in Hollywood history, leaving behind a grieving husband and three children.

Fred Astaire’s Grief: A Turning Point in His Life & Career

Fred Astaire was devastated by Phyllis’ death and nearly withdrew completely from filmmaking. During the production of Daddy Long Legs, he even offered to reimburse the studio for all expenses so he could quit the film. Producers and co-stars persuaded him to stay, but his grief was visible throughout the process. Astaire later admitted that he never fully recovered emotionally from losing Phyllis and described her death as losing “half of himself.” He remained a widower for 26 years until marrying Robyn Smith in 1980. Despite continuing his career, colleagues said his spirit was permanently changed by the loss of his beloved first wife.

Phyllis Potter’s Legacy in Classic Hollywood

Though she was not an actress or public figure, Phyllis Potter left a lasting mark on Hollywood through her influence on Fred Astaire’s life and work. Many biographers highlight her as the emotional foundation that allowed Astaire to achieve extraordinary success during their marriage. She appears in several Astaire documentaries, biographies, and retrospectives, always portrayed as elegant, supportive, and vital to his happiness. Her quiet strength, loyalty, and private nature made her an admired figure in Hollywood’s Golden Age circles. Today, historians continue to revisit her story because of her crucial but often overlooked role in shaping one of Hollywood’s greatest careers.

Public Misconceptions & Clarifications

Because Phyllis lived privately and died young, misinformation about her life is common. One misconception is confusion over her name—her correct birth name is Phyllis Livingston Baker, later known as Phyllis Potter after her first marriage. She was married twice, not multiple times as some sources claim. Another misconception relates to her role in Astaire’s professional decisions; while she encouraged and supported him, she did not act as his manager or advisor. Additionally, she should not be confused with other women named Phyllis Potter found in unrelated historical or public records. This section helps separate verified facts from online myths.

Family Lineage & Descendants

Phyllis Potter left behind three children who carried forward her family’s legacy. Her son Peter continued the Potter lineage privately, while Fred Astaire Jr. and Ava Astaire have maintained varying levels of public presence. Ava Astaire, in particular, has become an important figure in preserving her father’s history, attending public events, participating in documentaries, and maintaining archives related to Fred Astaire’s career. The family continues to honor their mother’s memory through private remembrance and selective historical projects. Through her children and grandchildren, Phyllis’ legacy extends into multiple generations.

Relationship With Fred Astaire’s Second Wife

It is important to clarify that Phyllis passed away 26 years before Fred Astaire married his second wife, Robyn Smith, in 1980. There was no overlap, conflict, or connection between the two women. Astaire remained devoted to Phyllis’ memory for decades and did not consider remarriage until late in life, at age 81. This clarification helps distinguish factual Hollywood history from accidental misconceptions.

Why Phyllis Potter’s Story Still Resonates Today

Phyllis Potter’s life resonates with modern audiences because her story reflects the human side of Hollywood’s Golden Age—a world often defined by glamour, fame, and artistic achievement. Her unwavering love and support helped shape the emotional foundation of one of cinema’s most iconic performers. Her tragic early death brought a deep sense of loss to Hollywood and changed the direction of Astaire’s life forever. Today, historians revisit her life not only because of her connection to Astaire but because she represents the quiet, often unseen influences behind great artists. Her story continues to be a powerful reminder of love, legacy, and loss.

Conclusion

Phyllis Potter’s journey from a privileged Boston upbringing to becoming the cherished wife of Fred Astaire reveals a life filled with elegance, devotion, and quiet influence. Her presence shaped the emotional and creative world of one of Hollywood’s greatest stars, supporting him through his most celebrated years. Although her life was tragically cut short, her impact endures through historical accounts, family memories, and Astaire’s enduring admiration. Her legacy remains central to understanding Fred Astaire’s story and the human experiences behind his legendary career. Phyllis’ life is remembered today as a touching blend of romance, resilience, and lasting significance in the history of classic Hollywood.

FAQs About Phyllis Potter

1. Who was Phyllis Potter?

Phyllis Potter, born Phyllis Livingston Baker in 1908, was an American socialite best known as the first wife of legendary dancer and actor Fred Astaire. She was a prominent figure in New York society and the mother of three children, including two with Astaire.

2. How did Phyllis Potter die?

Phyllis Potter died on September 13, 1954, at age 46 from lung cancer. Her death deeply affected her husband Fred Astaire, who was devastated and nearly withdrew from filming Daddy Long Legs due to grief.

3. When did Fred Astaire marry Phyllis Potter?

Fred Astaire married Phyllis Potter on July 12, 1933. Their marriage lasted 21 years until her death in 1954 and is remembered as one of classic Hollywood’s most loving and stable partnerships.

4. Did Phyllis Potter have children?

Yes. Phyllis Potter had three children: Eliphalet IV (“Peter”) from her first marriage, and two children with Fred Astaire—Fred Astaire Jr. (born 1936) and Ava Astaire (born 1942).

5. What was Phyllis Potter known for?

Phyllis Potter was known for her role as Fred Astaire’s devoted wife, her influence on his personal stability during his Hollywood prime, and her presence as a respected Boston-New York socialite. Her life and early death are often highlighted in biographies of Fred Astaire.

Read More: MySDMC SSO: The Ultimate Guide For Students, Parents & Teachers